BLUFF: Forgive me if this is a stupid question and for being long winded. I’m new to the mineral rights discussion and am learning every day. Is it possible to predict future royalties based on past production from wells in the same unit plus an unsolicited offer to buy the rights?
DETAILS:
My elderly mother has owned mineral rights Desoto Parish, LA, for decades (undivided 1/3 interest in a number of acres in two units in Holly Field). These rights are currently under two active leases. Significant (for her at least) royalties have been paid over the years but have been tapering off as expected. There have been no new wells in several years. I currently have PoA over her business affairs, and we have mostly completed her estate planning, including putting the mineral rights in trust to avoid dividing interests into even smaller shares between myself and siblings when mom passes.
We received an unsolicited offer for the acreage located in one of the units. The offer was probably close to 30 times the most recent 3-year average royalty income attributed to the offered acres. This eye-popping multiplier caused me to start learning about the O&G mineral rights and royalty game, including pooling and allocation. I’ve also been researching using SONRIS.
From SONRIS, I was able to determine that permits for 4 new wells have been granted on the unit in question. These proposed wells cross 2 units and the laterals are around 10,000’ with about 50% in each unit. The 4 wells run parallel to existing wells in the wider “open” spaces remaining in the units. The existing wells in mom’s unit produced significant royalties at their peak around 15 years ago.
We’re still not interested in selling because 1) an initial unsolicited offer is probably low, 2) mom would take a significant capital gains hit due to the 15% depletion deduction being taken for years of royalties, and 3) mom still wants to honor her grandmother from whom she inherited the rights who advised her to never sell the mineral rights.
Before now, I was able to fairly predict mom’s annual income and tax liability and, with the help of her accountant, do her tax planning. Now we have the complication of dealing with this potential extra income. Although this a good problem to have, it would be nice to be able to have some idea of the future income. Which leads to my specific questions:
If an unsolicited offer is X, is 2X or 4X a reasonable estimate for the true value of the rights on the open market?
Does the offer give a good indication of the expected royalties over the next 3-5 years?If so, what Cap Rate for the ROI is expected by investors in O&G mineral rights
Is the history of parallel well production a good indicator of production?If so how do you take into account distance between the parallel wells to get a high and low range?
If the wells are horizontal wells parallel to original horizontal wells, then the production from the previous wells can be a good guide (if in the same reservoir). If the wells are new horizontals and the old wells were vertical, then the new wells will be substantially much better.
Many buyers offer three-five years of production for the current wells and not so much for new wells since they plan to make a profit off of the new wells. They also discount for the time value of money over that time frame. Some buyers offer a little something for the new wells. Just depends. ROI depends upon internal company economics. First offers are usually low just to see who bites. In the “old days” for vertical wells, offers were typically four times last annual royalties for oil and seven times for gas. Horizontals are completely different as their decline curves are rapid in the first three years and then taper off and can last for decades.
Horizontal wells can last decades, so will benefit not only your mom in the near future, but the next generation as well. The next generation will get a step up in value on the minerals at her death, so mitigates the capital gains tax if they ever sell.
The directories tab above has several appraisers who can do a quick run for you. Pecan Tree does LA and west of the Mississippi states, so you could talk to them to get a better idea of her current wells and the possible new wells values. Then you have a bargaining chip if needed.
Product prices change of course over the years, so that is a factor. You are thinking wisely about how to get the minerals into a trust and keep them for the family’s future.
Thanks, Martha. I double checked the math, making sure I was limiting the royalties to the unit in question. My updated calculation is that the offer was actually 45 times the last year’s royalties. Although it’s nice think about the potential, I question the offer. There are there are 3 possibilities: 1) I misheard the offer, 2) the caller accidentally added an extra zero, or 3) the caller/offeror has VERY high expectations for the new wells. Occam’s razor leads me to surmise that 1 or 2 is most likely.
FWIW, the SONRIS LUW production data I found for the unit in question shows an average close to 950,000 MCF per month for 18 months at its peak 15 years ago, with the highest single month at over 2,000,000 MCF. There are currently about 15 actively producing wells in the unit. I haven’t checked the permits on all the wells, but most, if not all of the producing wells are in the Haynesville formation in Holly Field, as are the new permitted wells. .
@Eduardo66 double check with your tax advisor, but I don’t believe you recapture the 15% statutory depletion taken over the years — only any cost depletion taken. Most royalty owners don’t have the resources to calculate cost depletion.
For minerals, the basis is reduced by either cost or percentage depletion down to zero. Once the basis is zero, the mineral owner takes only percentage depletion annually. There is no recapture of either cost or percentage depletion upon sale of the minerals. It is not unusual for long-term mineral owners to have a zero basis at the time of sale of producing minerals and so all the sales proceeds are capital gains.
Thanks for pointing that out. Mom’s CPA may have it confused. She has been doing mom’s taxes for at least of decade. She told me she was following the predecessor CPA’s use of statutory depletion. But in the same conversation, she mentioned depletion recovery taxed as ordinary income. My quick research based your comment says the CPA and I need to have further discussions.
However, this is probably a moot point. Unless there is a significant change in circumstances, we won’t be selling while mom is still with us and probably any time in the foreseeable future after she is gone.
There was no question about a capital gain. We were concerned whether it would be the max LTCG of 20% versus recapture of depletion taxed as ordinary income.
Those four new wells could be significant. If those wells are where I think they are, they may be in the deep Haynesville. I would hang onto the minerals.
Are you able to share a per acre number you were offered? That would likely be the easiest way for people to tell you if your offer is attractive or not.
I intended to reply earlier, but have been very busy.
First, the initial offer is virtually always “unsolicited”. Only after receiving several offers would an owner even know where to get an offer. Buyers are constantly looking for opportunities. The only indication of an offer is that you have an asset of value.
I manage property in the Holly Field. The Holly field was originally a Cotton Valley and Hosston field, all vertical wells, and most are very well played out. So my question is how many of the wells already drilled that you’re talking about are Haynesville wells? I’m guessing only 2 if there are plans for four more.
Next, on the very early horizontal Haynesville wells, sometimes the LUW included the production from both sections. So, a double check of the production attributed to your section would be good. Also the LUW can include production from the Cotton Valley and Hosston wells in the unit. The LUW is total production that goes into the pipeline, not the production from one well. ( You’ve probably already figured that out.)
To get an idea of future production, it is always good to also look at the production of the wells in the units to the east and west of your unit, and even to the north and south. Are there plans for new wells in those units. Also, is the operator an aggressive operator. Does the operator have a large inventory of undrilled lease acreage. Does the operator own the leases in the adjoining sections?
I respect your desire to honor your mother’s wishes. I don’t try to sell owners on selling their minerals or royalty, but one must remember it is a financial asset that will decline in value because of the decline curve. I have a client who declined a seven digit offer 3 years ago. Their royalty income over the past 3 years has only been about 1/2 of that offer. This is on two very good cross unit wells.
In this case, if you were to consider selling, I would recommend that you only sell royalty interest.
It is worth, doing a lot of research, and then it boils down to what is your risk tolerance.
Thanks for the insight. I’m continuing find more to research with every comment. The wells on the unit are a mix of verticals in Hosston and Cotton Valley and laterals in Haynesville. Both the verticals and laterals are earning royalties each month, although they are far less than their peak. All the laterals are under a single LUW and none are cross unit. The newly permitted wells cross cross units which fill in unused space between the existing laterals in both units.
I haven’t checked the proposed depths of the permitted laterals to compare against the existing, but can only assume the operator is experienced enough to know how to maximize his return. This operator has obtained a number of permits and started drilling in Holly field in the last year. More research is needed to find production figures on the recent wells.
FWIW, the best 2 years of production for the LUW in our unit was 850k MCF/month. For the LUW in the connected unit that will share the new wells, the best 2 years was a little over 900k MCF/month.
I realize the risk holding for future royalties versus taking a cash offer. Thankfully, we are not in position that forces a sale to generate quick cash. I think we going to hold tight, unless the offer gets stupid high.