Naive seller signed broad buyer friendly mineral deed

We assumed the boiler plate was there to allow the buyer to investigate if there were any encumbrances and was standard fare. But now reading it closer it looks like the legal liability could far exceed the payment for a small share of a (about net 1 acre) of much larger plot (over 300 acres). The buyer found no encumbrances. But still I’m having seller’s remorse. The buyer wants to get more family members on board, especially one that owns the lion’s share. The buyer has shown some willingness to change to a specialty deed although there are still some exposure such as any litigation arising from issue before we knew we even had the acre.

The lesson to self and everyone else of course is that I should have had representation from the get go. The value of the offer for our little plot was just $3,500. So part of the hubris was not wanting to spend $1,500 on lawyers (I don’t know what it would have really been) to review things with just a possible $3,500 payment. I’ve contacted the law firm that completed the decree of distribution from the trust of the relative who passed on these mineral rights. But they never actually got deeds issued. The buyer wants to speak with them to get things moving along. I’d like to talk with them to get their take and am awaiting a call back. The original attorney passed in the interim.

Sorry for the long ramble. Any words of wisdom from the more experienced would be welcome.

Assuming you are a mineral owner, there is very little likelihood of any liability, especially from ownership of one net acre. Further, anybody wanting to sue would look at a simple mineral owner and determine collection of any judgment is unlikely.

No guarantees, but I would rest easy. P.S. Most lawyers wouldn’t have charged what you assumed above.

1 Like

So, what exactly is your concern over the legal liability that you are sharing?

Thank you!

Primarily that there’s no cap on my having to compensate the buyer for litigation issues originating before the transaction and no time limit. And second that the mineral deed references the larger plot’s mineral rights not just my little portion - which is referenced in the order of payment. I never did receive any funds from the OOP as I think that 30 days went by. I never did receive the $10 noted in the mineral deed either.