Compaass Mgt. Deceased Account Change

I am trying to help my 90 year old mother-in-law with Compass Management. She is the sole heir of the mineral rights. Her significant other was in poor health with dementia and making purchases. Some companies were sending checks & mailings directly to him. We contacted those companies and 4 companies have transferred ownership. We only stumbled across Compass Mangement/Noble name because there was unclaimed money in NY & TX for the decedent attached with their company name. The 4 companies we had been in touch with happened before we contacted Compass. Compass Management is now saying that we shouldn’t have contacted companies and had accounts transferred. Compass states they have over $18,000 in suspense and initially said it would cost $12,000 to transfer. Now they are saying since we have been in contact with 4 companies and had the transfer complete that Compass cannot complete the account transfer. Can anyone advise how to proceed or what attorney we should contact?? I have requested a copy of the agreement Compass had with decedent as well as what holdings they manage several times, but never get that information. What a dilemma!!

Is this the company, Compass Royalty Management?

Yes, can you help me?

Yes

Compass is a mineral management company. The agreement that your mother in law had with Compass is contractual in nature. If your mother in law’s significant other was making contracts on her behalf but had dementia there may be a lack of capacity argument that could possibly void the contract.

Compass is taking 2/3– over 60% of the money that your mother in law had in suspense. To me that sounds unconscionable, which is also grounds for setting aside a contract.

This is not my area of law though.

You don’t need a mineral rights lawyer on this issue. You need a contracts lawyer who understands Texas contracts law and arbitration. Most likely the agreement will have an arbitration clause. I suggest you hire a gunslinger who can compel them to provide the contract, then they will let you know what your options are.

I did a little AI searching and found this firm:

I would do your own investigation and see what you find.

An Elder Law Attorney may be useful in this matter. Since you are dealing with lack of capacity issues due to dementia and maybe something like undue influence from your mother-in-law’s significant other, an Elder Law Attorney may be helpful too and help you bring in the right counsel to untangle the mess that the significant other, suffering from dementia, may have unfortunately caused.

Best of luck on this.

Situations like this highlight how important it is to have a clear, documented history of mineral ownership and account activity, especially when an interest passes from one generation to the next.

One practical approach is to organize the available deeds, probate documents, ownership records, and correspondence into a timeline. From there, identify what has been verified, what documentation is still missing, and which questions need to be answered by the company managing the interest.

I would also recommend keeping a written record of all requests and responses. If ownership or payment questions remain unresolved, a qualified mineral title attorney may be able to help determine the appropriate next steps.

Hopefully you’re able to get some clarity and resolution soon.

The account was in the significant other’s name who has passed away. We are just trying to get the account in my mother-in-law’s name. We submitted all legal paperwork to Compass and have had account access with them since April, but they won’t transfer titles to her or release funds now because we had already been following up with other companies we were receiving direct mailings/checks from. We just followed other companies instructions and had those rights re-titled. Compass acts like we did something illegal, which certainly was not our intent! I just questioned Compass about needing division orders like we have gotten from other companies and that opened a can of worms - with them asking why we were dealing with other companies….i guess the other companies are direct drillers we are dealing with. I don’t understand any of this stuff with mineral rights!! We only found Compass name inadvertently when we found some unclaimed funds in decedents name. I had no idea that Compass was supposedly managing all funds. But obviously Compass wasn’t managing properly as we have received delinquent tax notices and were receiving checks from other companies.

I’m assuming the decedent just kept buying from companies and never let Compass know, with his decline in mental status. Due to wrong address the compass acct has been in suspense since 2021, and owner died in 2021. We just found the compass company name in March 2026.

The significant other was in ill health, had dementia and did not keep any documents - they were either thrown out by landlord or by decedent in his declining mental state.

Did your mother already own the minerals that X was managing for her or did X own the minerals that he was managing for himself? Minerals ownership is based on deed recorded in the county records. If X owned the minerals, then presumably there is a will and probate to transfer title in the county records. Did X contract with Compass to manage his separate minerals or was he purchasing minerals or working interests through Compass or others in his name? Or was he purchasing minerals through an investment fund which were held in the name of Compass? You need to get a copy of the Compass contract. This should have been done by the estate attorney. If Compass is refusing to send it to you, then your attorney can intercede. Also ask for copies of the monthly income and asset reports / annual reports / and 1099’s that Compass issued over the years. Unfortunately, this is the kind of mess that can occur when family is not monitoring or assisting aging relatives who become less able to manage their assets. They sign contracts that they do not fully understand or lease without knowing current bonus and lease terms. Documentation and information disappears. Then tracking becomes a problem for heirs. Did a CPA or professional prepare the tax returns? They might have copies of the 1099s.

The estate attorney died. What files he had was sent to another attorney and their paralegal did minimal work to get this straightened out and never was able to get anything sorted so sent me what little info was available.

I’m handling on my own for my mother-in-law. I’ve managed to get 4 major companies to put account in mother in law’s name and have checks coming in.

The contract with Compass was NOT signed by mother in law. The decedent signed contract for his own purposes. This is inherited rights we are trying to get transferred to my mother in law.

Finds have been in suspense since 2021 with Compass. We just found this out in Match 2026 and have been trying to get the account changed. They are holding over $18,000 in suspense and refuse to release.

The companies that xrayeyes2u is dealing with are connected to Noble Royalties (not to be confused with Noble Energy). If anyone has ever looked at a conveyance involving Noble Royalties, you will note that Noble kept the executive rights and conveyed the beneficial rights to pages and pages of grantees. The grantees were conveyed a small, and I mean less than 1%, interest in numerous properties across 14 states. A lot of the grantees were investors. Many financial advisors put their clients into these funds. I have a client who has been trying to transfer these funds into his self-directed IRA for over a year; it is still not accomplished.

I don’t have any answers other than to say much of the advice given doesn’t apply in this situation. Compass is not an operator who owns a leasehold and has wells and isn’t paying their royalty owner. They are an investment vehicle, much like a stock or a mutual fund.

I tried to find an attorney who had sued them in the past but couldn’t find a record of any suits involving this. Further, as Mr. Jones suspected, the underlying contract has an arbitration clause.

In May 2025, my client was in contact with a representative of Compass and they said they had a large queue of people waiting to get their interest titled in their name.

If there is a lesson to be learned, which is no consolation to you, it is that ordinary people or even extraordinary people should not make oil and gas investments without legal assistance.

1 Like