From what I understand, if you receive a pooling order because you haven’t signed a lease, you’ll be given royalty options with a signing bonus, just like a lease offer from a landman. Here’s a cut and paste AI blurp, it’s correct so I didn’t have to type it out.
You could still get a good bonus potentially on a 1/4 royalty. It will be the lowest bonus offer for sure because of highest royalty rate, and it could be zero. Won’t know until a pooling order arrives.
In Oklahoma, during the forced pooling process, the royalty and bonus rates are determined by an Administrative Law Judge at the Oklahoma Corporation Commission (OCC) hearings. The judge bases these rates on the “fair market value” established by recent, voluntary lease transactions within your specific drilling unit and the eight surrounding units. [1, 2, 3]
How the Rates are Determined
Before setting the rates, the operating company must present evidence of what they (or competitors) have been paying mineral owners in the immediate vicinity. Based on this testimony, the OCC issues a Pooling Order that offers unleased mineral owners a choice of several options that balance bonus payouts against royalty percentages. [1, 2, 3, 4]
The options typically follow a sliding scale—meaning as the royalty rate goes up, the cash bonus goes down: [1, 2]
-
High Bonus / Low Royalty: For example, $1,000 per net mineral acre with a 1/8th (12.5%) royalty.
-
Mid-Range Combinations: For example, $750/acre with a 3/16th (18.75%) royalty, or $500/acre with a 1/5th (20%) royalty.
-
Zero Bonus / High Royalty: For example, no upfront cash bonus, but a 1/4th (25%) royalty. [1, 2]
Your Action Required
Once the OCC issues the pooling order, you are given a strict, non-negotiable deadline (typically 20 calendar days) to review the options and respond to the operator. [1, 2]
If you fail to make an election in writing by the deadline, you are usually assigned the default option by the commission, which is almost always the lowest royalty rate and highest cash bonus (or sometimes no bonus at all). [1, 2]