# Another Royalty Deduction

**URL:** https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265
**Category:** General Mineral Rights Discussion
**Created:** [September 14, 2014, 1:19am UTC](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265 "2014-09-14T01:19:40Z")
**Posts on this page:** 4
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Wilson\_Inc](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/user_avatar/www.mineralrightsforum.com/wilson_inc/32/4426_2.png) [@Wilson\_Inc](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/u/Wilson_Inc)
#### Post date: [September 14, 2014, 1:19am UTC](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265/1 "2014-09-14T01:19:40Z")

</div>

The trial court awarded French $10,074,262.33 in underpaid royalties. The court of appeals reversed.

In French vs. Occidental Permian, Ltd. the Texas Supreme Court held that costs associated with injection of carbon dioxide into a reservoir in a tertiary recovery operation were properly deducted from royalties.

I thought that CO2 well injection costs are part of production cost therefore not deductible from royalty. I never thought it through to the CO2 ending up being in the production stream: Occidental processed the gas to remove the CO2 and extract the NGLs. This was the cost at issue.

The article is here:

CO2 is Good By Charles Sartain Co-author Mark Bohon on August 14th, 2014

> **[CO2 is Good](https://www.energyandthelaw.com/2014/08/14/co2-is-good/)**
>
> … in the right places. Co-author Mark Bohon In French vs. Occidental Permian, Ltd. the Texas Supreme Court held that costs associated with injection of

I do not know if there is a post production cost free royalty clause in French’s lease.

Does there need to be lease language specifically addressing the processing of injected CO2 as a cost free post production cost?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Buddy\_Cotten](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/user_avatar/www.mineralrightsforum.com/buddy_cotten/32/5079_2.png) [@Buddy\_Cotten](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/u/Buddy_Cotten)
#### Post date: [September 14, 2014, 8:24pm UTC](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265/2 "2014-09-14T20:24:39Z")

</div>

Dear Wilson Inc

Injected CO2 is typically used for a **tertiary** recovery operation or technique after primary production has ceased (can’t remove anymore by pump) and secondary operations have ceased (waterflood).

The Fieldwide Unitization Agreement, if drawn properly, addresses the production of and re-injection of CO2. There are some court cases that say that injected materials are personal property and when produced are still personal property and not real property where a royalty is entitled. It makes sense to me. The FUA supersedes the lease on conflicts like this.

Best Buddy Cotten

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![Wilson\_Inc](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/user_avatar/www.mineralrightsforum.com/wilson_inc/32/4426_2.png) [@Wilson\_Inc](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/u/Wilson_Inc)
#### Post date: [September 17, 2014, 9:01pm UTC](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265/3 "2014-09-17T21:01:23Z")

</div>

Dear Mr. Cotten,

Thank you for pointing out the difference between a lease and a FUA for tertiary recovery operations.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![system](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/uploads/db5755/original/3X/6/c/6c7c56608c843272ad6e3662ce9562a5956f173e.png) [@system](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/u/system)
#### Post date: [August 15, 2018, 12:18am UTC](https://www.mineralrightsforum.com/t/another-royalty-deduction/9265/4 "2018-08-15T00:18:46Z")

</div>


